That's just one story attached to the historic structure that St. George plans to restore. The city recently approved slightly more than $500,000 to begin renovating the building's exterior.
Alder applauds the city's commitment. "It's one of the seven original [public] buildings in St. George," he said.
Work on the courthouse began three years after St. George became the Washington County seat in 1863. The two-story building, built of sandstone and baked brick on a lava foundation, is located at 97 E. St. George Blvd. It has interior walls that are 18 inches thick, and original paintings of Zion Canyon and Grand Canyon still grace its upstairs walls.
A common case that was heard within the walls of its upstairs courtroom in the late 19th century was theft charges against ranchers and farmers accused of releasing irrigation water too early, Alder said. Today, visitors to the historic building can watch a re-enactment of a water theft trial.
"We always find them guilty," said Alder.
Alder tells another story about Will Brooks, a county sheriff in the early 19th century who was responsible for feeding the inmates. Alder said Brooks sometimes ignored jail procedure and took the prisoners home with him for a meal.
St. George Mayor Daniel McArthur said the city acquired the structure, adding to the National Register of Historic Places in 1970, from the county in the 1980s in a land swap. He said the building's roof and exterior walls need repairs. Drainage problems will also be addressed.
In early Feburary, the City Council appropriated $500,000 for exterior work on the recommendation of the city's Historic Preservation Committee.
"It's a bit more than we wanted, but worth it," he said of the cost. "It's a beautiful building that should be kept as a treasure of the past."
He said the interior will be restored during a second phase of the project in the future.
The basement jail space is now used for storage, while the Chamber of Commerce occupies the main floor. The former courtroom on the top floor is now used for lectures.
Miles Romney, who built the St. George LDS temple and tabernacle, also built the courthouse. It cost $10,000, which was raised by a tax hike approved by voters.
Richard Kohler, president of the Washington County Historical Society, said Romney, the great-great-grandfather of GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney, probably built the courthouse based on a design by William H. Folsom, who was then the architect for the Mormon Church.
Kohler said the courthouse is strikingly similar to the Council Hall building just south of the state Capitol in Salt Lake City, which also is based on a Folsom design. Kohler and others believe Council Hall may have been copied for the courthouse, including its cupola.
When buildings were constructed in the mid-19th century, he said, builders usually had just a picture to work from, not the detailed drawings architects produce today.
"He [Romney] probably just had a picture of the front and a drawing of a floor plan," he said.
He doubts the cupola was built with the express purpose of hanging criminals. "I don't know if there's ever been a [legal] hanging in the county," he said.
Still, McArthur said many still believe the cupola was indeed built for that purpose.
"My dad told me it was built for hangings, but none ever happened," he said. "I've always pictured it as a gallows with trap doors and everything."