The early decision by team Pham which included his Forage co-owner Bowman Brown and chef Luke Fowles to make ice cream from ground beef drippings sent host Alton Brown into a frenzy. "You're watching history, folks," he told viewers, of the ice cream that was eventually served with cherries cooked two ways and topped with beef fat powder and a cocoa and ground beef crumble.
Food writer and judge Simon Majumdar said the dessert sounded "ridiculous." But after tasting it, he gave it high praise: "It works. I've never heard of it. Never even considered it, yet I could eat every bit of it. It's delicious. Incredible."
While the beef fat ice cream got the most buzz, it was Pham's "First Dish" that got him the win. The First Dish is a new part of the Iron Chef competition in which each chef must serve a dish to judges in the first 20 minutes of the battle. Pham offered up a soft scrambled egg served in an egg shell and topped with maple syrup, sausage and cream. He received a score of 14 out of 15. Judge Ben Sargent called the creamy breakfast bite "amazing." On the flip side, Flay's sausage crepinette was deemed too salty and it received only 8 points.
Not every Pham dish was a success. Judged didn't like the beets with beef borscht. They said the ground beef was chewy and the dish lacked flavor.
Also new to "Iron Chef" is the "curve ball" ingredient, which is introduced about half way through the event and must be incorporated into one of the four remaining dishes. Sunday night it was prawns. Pham served his prawn raw, alongside halibut that had been poached in a hamburger/buttermilk whey. Flay served his crustacean with a chorizo meatball. The round was a draw, as both chefs scored 13 out of 15
In the scoring, the only place Flay actually beat Pham was in the overall taste category earning 27 out of 30 points. Pham received 25 points
This particular "Iron Chef" episode was filmed in July. In the audience were Pham's Vietnamese-born parents, who immigrated to the United States when the chef and his brother were still young. Their presence made the win more meaningful, said Pham, who invited more than 100 friends and Utah food industry professionals to Naked Fish restaurant in downtown Salt Lake City last night to watch the episode and celebrate his win.
"To be able to beat an Iron Chef is surreal," said Pham, who was the runner-up on last year's edition of "Extreme Chef." "It was a dream."