Dake also is the only wrestler to win four titles at four different weight classes.
Dake received 41 of 43 first-place votes from the voting committee for the Hodge Trophy, which is generally considered the equivalent of the Heisman Trophy award for collegiate wrestling.
The committee is made up of former Hodge Trophy winners, media and retired college coaches.
Penn State's Ed Ruth got two first-place votes and finished second behind Dake.
The Hodge Trophy is presented by Iowa-based wrestling publication W.I.N magazine.