"I know better than that," Leyland said when asked if the Tigers have taken control of the division. "I'm no fool. This is one of those series you can't explain. Sometimes freaky things happen."
Max Scherzer became baseball's first 17-game winner and Miguel Cabrera drove in three runs as the AL Central leaders and opened a seven-game lead over the Indians. The series was billed as a battle between the division's two top teams, but the Tigers made it clear they're in charge.
"We came out here and played as good a four game series that we played all year," Scherzer said as the music blared loudly in Detroit's clubhouse. "Everybody played their best. All the starters, all the hitters, the relievers. Everybody did their jobs."
Indians manager Terry Francona understandably had a different point of view.
"Tonight was a tough night, and this was a terrible, a tough series," he said. "It's a hard way to play, but we'll come back (Friday) and see if we can do better."
Scherzer (17-1) allowed two runs and four hits in seven innings. He helped the Tigers beat Cleveland for the 12th time in their last 13 meetings.
The Tigers have won 12 in a row for the first time since Sept. 2-14, 2011.
Coupled with a 13-game winning streak by idle Atlanta, this marks the first time in major league history that two teams have had winning streaks of at least 12 games at the same time during a season since May 16, 1884, STATS said. That was the only other time it occurred the St. Louis Maroons had won 15 straight, the New York Gothams had taken 12 in a row.
"When we're able to execute as a team, we can do great things," Scherzer said. "That's why we think we're one of the best teams in the American League."
Cleveland's futility for the series was summed up when Francona let utilityman Ryan Raburn pitch the ninth inning. Raburn retired three straight hitters, striking out Matt Tuiasosopo, in his professional pitching debut and drew a standing ovation.
Cabrera drew a bases-loaded walk during a six-run third and hit a two-run single in the fifth, giving him 105 RBIs this season.
That gave Scherzer a huge cushion. He retired the first nine hitters, struck out five and one. He also recorded the 1,000th strikeout of his career when he fanned Jason Kipnis to end the first.
Scherzer threw 100 pitches, and left with a 2.84 ERA this year. The right-hander is 4-0, allowing four earned runs in 28 1-3 innings, since starting for the AL in the All-Star game.
"He's always good," Leyland said. "He was pretty much vintage Max."
Zach McAllister (4-7) allowed six runs in 2 1-3 innings, his shortest start of the season.
Asdrubal Cabrera drove in Cleveland's only runs off Scherzer with RBI doubles in the fourth and sixth.
McAllister's short outing forced Francona to empty his bullpen, which was already taxed by Wednesday's 14-inning game. Preston Guilmet, Matt Albers and Marc Rzepczynski got the Indians through the eighth but Francona needed one more arm for the ninth.
The 25,131 fans cheered wildly when Raburn fanned Tuiasosopo and retired Hernan Perez and Brayan Pena on groundouts. Raburn became the first position player to pitch for the Indians since Andy Marte threw one inning against the Yankees on July 29, 2010.
Detroit began sending its message in the series opener. Detroit rallied off Indians closer Chris Perez in the ninth inning for a 4-2 win on Monday. Justin Verlander allowed one run in eight dominant innings in Tuesday's 5-1 victory. Cabrera's home run off rookie Danny Salazar was the key blow Wednesday and the Tigers went on to win 6-5 in 14 innings.
With the momentum clearly on their side, the Tigers struck early in the finale, sending 11 batters to the plate in the third. Cabrera walked for Detroit's first run before Prince Fielder and Victor Martinez added two-run doubles.