There can be compelling financial incentives to go without an agent. The for-sale-by-owner approach can save sellers big money on agent sales commissions, which typically run 6 percent of the sale price. On a home that sells for $300,000, that's $18,000 that would typically be split between a seller's agent and the agent representing the buyer. Both are typically paid by the seller.
Magelky estimated that he saved $10,000 by not paying agent commissions. "It's just cutting out the middleman," said Magelky. His home took eight months to sell.
Historically, for-sale-by-owner transactions accounted for between 15 to 20 percent of the market, according to the National Association of Realtors. The figure tends to go up when the market is hot and it's easier for sellers to go it alone, and declines during a down market because there's a glut of unsold properties.
Since early 2012, steady job gains and low mortgage rates have fueled a rebound in housing, setting the market on a recovery path following the worst housing bust in decades. For-sale-by-owner home sales made up a record-low 9 percent of all sales last year, the NAR said.
But homeowners who sell their property on their own may not always be able to tap the pool of buyers that an agent can in the open market, which could reduce the range of offers. And the process of selling a home can be painstaking and confusing, potentially more trouble than it's worth especially if the seller is on a time crunch to get a home sold.
Here are five tips for how to tackle a home sale without enlisting a sales agent:
Consider if you're up for the task
Selling a home on your own means handling a lot of tasks that an experienced real estate agent would normally take on, including listing the home, reaching out to a network of buyers' agents, preparing the home for viewing and dealing directly with prospective buyers.
In broad strokes, selling a home requires pricing the property, promoting it until you find a buyer who makes an offer and sealing the deal.
If you don't have the time to devote to stay on top of the process, it could take you longer to sell the house and maybe result in a lower sales price.
Get help determining your asking price
Figuring out the best price to list your home requires knowledge of the local market trends. It's the type of information that agents have at their fingertips, but it's not exclusive to them.
"You have to take an honest look at what you're selling, and establishing price can sometimes be the most difficult thing," said Paul Jarvis, a certified financial planner based in Fargo, N.D.
Experts suggest hiring a property appraiser to gauge the value of your home relative to comparable properties that have sold in your area. That typically runs a few hundred dollars, but it will help provide reassurance that you're pricing your property realistically.
If you skip the appraisal, you can glean some insights on real estate websites that help walk sellers through the pricing process. At Forsalebyowner.com/pricingguide/seller, the tool costs $40.
The first step in getting your home sold is to make would-be buyers aware that it's on the market.
Before the Internet, this often meant relying on a "for sale" sign in the yard and an ad in the newspaper. Now there are many websites that allow homeowners to post photos and descriptions of their home. Some cater specifically to for-sale-by-owner listings, including ForSaleByOwner.com, Owners.com and Fizber.com. Other options include popular real estate portals Zillow.com and Trulia.com. All allow homeowners to put up listings for free.
For $99, USRealty.com lists a seller's home in local multiple listing services (MLS) plus key national sites, such as Realtor.com.
Experts advise taking good photos you can look at listings for homes represented by agents as a guide. That typically means making sure interiors are well lit and exterior shots are taken on a sunny day with a good camera, said Colby Sambrotto, president of USRealty.com.
Once you start receiving inquiries from buyers interested in visiting your home, it may be tempting to drop everything and have them come over. Experts suggest sellers resist that impulse, and set up a small window of time every week for buyers to drop in. That will make it easier to manage the visits, and create a sense of urgency among buyers when they run into others taking a look at the home.
Get help with paperwork
Unless you're comfortable drawing up agreements on payment and closing terms, consider bringing in an attorney to help put the finishing touches on the deal. Another option is offering a smaller percentage of the sale, say 1 percent, or a flat fee to a real estate agent for their help in nailing down the last details of an agreement.
Of course, you can do it on your own. A basic agreement can be as simple as the price, how the buyer will pay (cash or a loan), and the closing date.
That's what Magelky did.
"It wasn't too complicated," he said. "It's intimidating, but once you get into it, it isn't really that tough."