Just before Mendenhall stepped to the podium, highly touted defensive end Uriah Leiataua of Compton, Calif., a Stanford commit, announced he was flipping to BYU and would sign with the Cougars. Leiataua, who apparently changed his mind after visiting Provo last weekend, was the last player to sign, bringing the total to 12 defensive players and eight offensive players.
Mendenhall crowed that Leiataua's signing meant BYU went head-to-head with powerful USC for four players and won three of those battles. The other two were Nick Kurtz, a receiver from Grossmont College who signed with BYU in December and is already enrolled in Provo, and Fred Warner, a four-star linebacker from San Marcos, Calif., who committed to the Cougars almost a year ago, but visited USC the middle of last week and received a late scholarship offer from the Trojans.
"I am pretty confident that we have done a good job," Mendenhall said. "How to rank it on a BYU class scale? I am not sure. On a national scale, I am not sure how to rank it. But it has been a great day, not just a good day. It's been a great day."
BYU also announced the 18 returning missionaries who will join the team this year.
They are LBs Austin Heder, Va'a Nuimatalolo, Phillip Amone, Troy Hinds and Adam Pulsipher; DLs Tanner Balderree, Graham Rowley, Kesni Tausinga, Travis Tuiloma and Steven Richards; QB McCoy Hill; TEs Colby Jorgensen and Matt Sumsion; OLs Corbin Kaufusi, Ului Lapuaho, Manu Mulitalo and Brian Rawlinson; And kicker Corey Edwards.
The day started with good and bad news for the Cougars.
The bad news was that Damien Mama, a 6-foot-4, 370-pound offensive lineman from Bellflower, Calif., signed with USC. Mama, who is LDS and has said he will go on an LDS Church mission after his first season of college football, visited BYU last weekend and had the Cougars in his final three, along with Alabama.
Mama was rated as the No. 1 offensive guard in the country by several recruiting services.
The early good news was that Warner, a four-star linebacker from San Marcos, Calif., signed with BYU around 11 a.m. MST, keeping the commitment he made last summer despite offers from USC, Washington and other nationally prominent programs.
Warner is arguably the biggest prize of Bronco Mendenhall's 2014 class, given the competition the coach faced to land the 6-foot-3, 210-pound playmaker who the Cougars hope can eventually replace All-America LB Kyle Van Noy.
Warner recorded 90 tackles at Mission Hills High School, 24 tackles for loss, and 13 sacks despite not playing full games in five of 10 regular-season contests.
"There have been other classes that have been highly heralded that didn't pan out that way," Mendenhall said, perhaps referring to the 2010 class that included five-star quarterback Jake Heaps, now at Kansas. "I am not as concerned about the fanfare, but I feel really good about what I think this class is capable of doing, in relation to our program, at this time."
Also Wednesday, BYU's receiving corps - trying to replace Cody Hoffman, the most prolific pass-catcher in school history - got significantly better and more experienced.
UTEP's Jordan Leslie and Devon Blackmon, who played last season at Riverside City College in California - signed with BYU.
Leslie, a 6-3, 210-pound senior from Houston, will graduate from UTEP in May with a degree in engineering and will enroll in a graduate program at BYU. That means he will be immediately eligible to play his final season of college football at BYU.
In three years, Leslie caught 125 passes for 2,015 yards and 15 touchdowns. His numbers fell his junior season after he caught 51 passes for 973 yards as a sophomore when current BYU receivers coach Guy Holliday was his position coach. He caught 44 passes for 612 yards in 2013.
The 6-1, 185-pound Blackmon was a high school teammate of current Cougar RB Jamaal Williams. He signed with Oregon out of high school as one of the fastest players in the 2011 class, but transferred to Riverside CC, near his hometown of Fontana, Calif. He will have two years to play two seasons.
It wasn't all good news for BYU, however.
Oregon State announced that former Bingham High defensive lineman Baker Pritchard, who signed with BYU before going on an LDS Church mission, has signed with the Beavers.
Mendenhall said he immediately released Pritchard to sign with OSU when the DL approached him a few weeks ago.
Also, BYU was in the running for Courtland Sutton, a safety from Brenham, Texas, who visited Provo the weekend that the Cougars beat Texas. However, Sutton announced Wednesday morning that he has signed with SMU.
The first future Cougars to get their letters of intent in were Jaterrius Gulley, a defensive lineman from Hoover, Ala., and Trey Dye, a receiver from Abilene, Texas. Dye is the son of former BYU kick and punt returner James Dye. Shortly after their letters arrived, BYU received a letter from one of three Utahns who signed with them Wednesday, Syracuse defensive back Kavika Fonua.
Pleasant Grove defensive lineman Zac Dawe and Matt Bushman, a tight end from Tucson, Ariz., also got their letters in before 8 a.m. MST. Then came a letter from Brighton High's Isaiah Kaufusi, a receiver and outside linebacker who is the cousin of defensive line starter Bronson Kaufusi.
Then came etters from Austin Chambers, an offensive lineman from Shawnee Mission, Kan., and Teancum "Tico" Fuga, a defensive lineman from Huntington Beach, Calif.
Fuga is the younger brother for former BYU star lineman Romney Fuga.
Tyler Cook, a linebacker from Murrieta, Calif., also joined the fold. Cook shined at Vista Murrieta High School and chose the Cougars over Arizona and others.
More offensive linemen added their names to the list later Wednesday morning, including Tejan Koroma, a 6-foot, 255-pounder from Allen, Texas, and Chandon Herring, a towering 6-7 tackle from Gilbert, Ariz.
Defensive tackle Earl Mariner, a 6-4, 300-pounder from Topeka, Kan., signed just before Leiataua did.
High schooler Michael Shelton of Raleigh, N.C. (Wakefield H.S) and Kurtz, of El Cajon, Calif., signed with BYU in December and have already enrolled.
Timpview High's Isaiah Nacua, a defensive end who transferred to the high school in Provo after playing his junior season at Bishop Gorman High in Las Vegas, also signed with BYU. Nacua, brother of current BYU safety Kai Nacua, committed to BYU a year ago, then re-opened his recruitment when he moved to Utah to play for Timpview.
Mendenhall and Martzen, who appeared at the news conference to answer questions about the class, said they might add a quarterback to class if they find one they believe can help them.
"There might be an additional addition to this class at quarterback, over some point," Mendenhall said. "I really won't or can't say any more than that. But I will examine hard whether we want that to happen. If not, we will certainly address it in the fall."
BYU signing class
Player Hometown School Pos Ht Wt
Trey Dye Cooper, Texas Cooper H.S. WR 5-11 175
Son of former BYU kickoff and punt returner James Dye
Kavika Fonua Syracuse, Utah Syracuse H.S. DB 6-0 200
One of state's best athletes picked BYU over Utah in August
Jaterrius Gulley Hoover, Ala. Hoover H.S. DL 6-3 325
Helped his high school team win back-to-back state titles
Zac Dawe Pleasant Grove, Utah Pleasant Grove H.S. OL 6-4 260
Heavyweight is two-time All-American in wrestling
Matt Bushman Tucson, Ariz. Sabino H.S. TE 6-5 205
Rated as the No. 10 tight end in the West by Scout.com
Isaiah Kaufusi Salt Lake City, Utah Brighton H.S. DB 6-2 175
Cousin of BYU star Bronson Kaufusi
Tyler Cook Murrieta, Calif. Vista Murrieta H.S. LB 6-3 220
Three-star linebacker chose BYU over Arizona, others
Jordan Leslie Houston, Texas UTEP WR 6-3 210
Has one year of eligibility remaining, can play right away
Devon Blackmon Fontana, Calif. Riverside City College WR 6-1 185
Jamaal Williams' former high school teammate
Teancum "Tico" Fuga Huntington Beach, Calif. Edison H.S. DL 6-2 320
Brother of former Cougar great Romney Fuga
Austin Chambers Shawnee Mission, Kan. West H.S. OL 6-5 285
Will go on a church mission before joining Cougars
Tejan Koroma Allen, Texas Allen H.S. OL 6-0 250
Committed after watching BYU edge Houston at Reliant Stadium
Chandon Herring Gilbert, Ariz. Perry H.S. OL 6-7 260
Also played defensive tackle, recorded 30 tackles
Fred Warner San Marcos, Calif. Mission Hills H.S. LB 6-3 210
Had offers from USC, Washington; Big get for the Cougars
Isaiah Nacua Provo, Utah Timpview H.S. DE 6-2 255
Committed last summer, then again this past week
Sione Takitaki Menifee, Calif. Heritage H.S. DE 6-3 240
Rated the No. 8 defensive end in the West by Scout.com
Earl Mariner Topeka, Kan. Washburn Rural H.S. OL 6-4 300
Two-star lineman committed last June after Junior Day
Uriah Leiataua Compton, Calif. Dominguez H.S. DL 6-3 245
Cougars lured him away from early Stanford commitment
Michael Shelton Raleigh, N.C. Wakefield H.S. DB 5-8 170
Graduated early, signed in December, enrolled in January
Nick Kurtz El Cajon, Calif. Grossmont CC WR 6-6 205
Cougars hope mid-year transfer can fill Cody Hoffman's shoes
BYU's returning missionaries
Player Hometown School Pos Ht Wt
Austin Heder Pleasant Grove, Utah Pleasant Grove H.S. LB 6-1 241
Va'a Niumatalolo Annapolis, Md. Broadneck H.S. LB 6-1 227
Phillip Amone Orlando, Fla. Dr. Phillips H.S. LB 6-0 230
Troy Hinds Kaysville, Utah Davis H.S. LB 6-0 230
Adam Pulsipher Temecula, Calif. Temecula Valley H.S. LB 6-2 230
Tanner Balderree Sherwood, Ore. Sherwood H.S. DL 6-3 230
Graham Rowley Waialua, Hawaii Waialua H.S. DL 6-4 280
Kesni Tausinga South Jordan, Utah Bingham H.S. DL 6-1 285
Travis Tuiloma Topeka, Kan. Washburn Rural H.S. DL 6-2 320
Steven Richards Sandy, Utah Alta H.S. DL 6-4 240
McCoy Hill Sandy, Utah Jordan H.S. QB 6-5 230
Colby Jorgensen Provo, Utah Timpview H.S. TE 6-7 230
Matt Sumsion Springville, Utah Springville H.S. TE 6-8 215
Corbin Kaufusi Provo, Utah Timpview H.S. OL 6-8 255
Ului Lapuaho West Valley, Utah Hunter H.S. OL 6-7 280
Manu Mulitalo West Valley, Utah Granger H.S. OL 6-2 340
Brian Rawlinson Oologah, Okla. Oologah H.S. OL 6-6 280
Corey Edwards Hurricane, Utah Hurricane H.S. K 5-10 190