Utah mine safety post filled after 16-month vacancy
Government • The Legislature denied a funding request.
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2011, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

After being vacant for 16 months, the Utah Office of Coal Mine Safety is functioning again, with mining veteran David Houghton's appointment to run the operation on a part-time basis.

A resident of Carbonville, north of Price, Houghton has worked in several Carbon and Emery County coal mines during a 36-year career. He did not respond to a call Tuesday for comment.

The one-person office was created by the 2008 Legislature in response to the Crandall Canyon mine disaster. Nine miners were killed and six injured in August 2007 by a pair of wall implosions in the Emery County mine.

A commission led by former U.S. Attorney Scott Matheson Jr. was appointed by then-Gov. Jon Huntsman to review ways to enhance the state's role in mine safety. It made nearly 50 recommendations, but lawmakers settled for only creating an office that had no enforcement powers, primarily collected information about safety plans at the state's eight active mines and served as the state's liaison to the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration.

Mining industry veteran Garth Nielsen held the position for two years. But he resigned in March 2010 to take a higher-paying job with coal-haulage company Savage Industries Inc.

The position within the Utah Labor Commission has been vacant since then, largely because of commission budget cuts.

"We were able to fulfill the requirements of the statute [creating the office] with existing personnel," said Labor Commissioner Sherrie Hayashi, noting that a funding request before the 2011 Legislature went nowhere.

"But with the importance of filling that position, we managed to find some money" within the commission, she said. Houghton will be paid $32 an hour but no benefits.

The state's decision not to hire a replacement for Nielsen was criticized at the time by Daniel Kane, United Mine Workers of America international secretary-treasurer, as a signal that "safety is way down the list in Utah."

Mike Dalpiaz, a UMWA international board member from Price and a member of the state's Mine Safety Technical Advisory Committee, has known Houghton for decades and considers him "really conscientious."

But the position Houghton is inheriting is basically that of a figurehead, Dalpiaz added. "Legislators don't care about that position any more than the man in the moon," he said. "They won't care about mine safety until we have another Crandall Canyon." mikeg@sltrib.comTwitter: @sltribmikeg