Marriage isn't in nature

This is an archived article that was published on in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Pope Benedict XVI argued that the reasons against marriage are "inscribed in human nature itself." The argument that something is desirable merely because it is natural, or undesirable merely because it is unnatural, is called the "appeal to nature," and any class in logic will tell you that it is a fallacious argument.

The values one seeks in nature are really your values, not nature's. For example, an advertiser may claim that its product is "all natural," implying that it is environmentally friendly or safe. However, many toxic substances are "all natural," including lead, hemlock and poisonous mushrooms.

The pope's assertion of "the natural structure of marriage as the union of a man and a woman" is laughable. Marriage is not in nature; it is a human social construct that has changed as human values have changed.

Anyway, isn't part of being civilized that we rise above nature to truth, love, compassion, justice and equality? And those values argue for allowing gays to marry. Nature has nothing to do with it.

Alan Smith

Salt Lake City