Lehi day care owner acquitted of molesting young girls
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

A Lehi day care owner was acquitted by a jury Wednesday night of sexually abusing several young girls at the facility.

Alfredo Vargas, 45, was charged in 4th District Court with 15 counts of aggravated sexual abuse of a child, a first-degree felony, for allegedly molesting four girls between the ages of 1 and 8 at his day care center, Little Bears Academy, beginning in June 2011.

But jurors, after six days of trial and about three hours of deliberation, found Vargas not guilty of all counts.

Vargas' trial began last week, when a jury heard testimony from three of the alleged victims,Charging documents say three girls told police that Vargas had touched their private parts multiple times, and two of them said it had happened every day since they began attending the day care.

But Vargas, who testified Wednesday, claimed an alibi: that another person — his brother — was with him when the abuse allegedly occurred.

But Deputy Utah County Attorney Craig Johnson that the brother gave contradictory testimony, indicating he was gone most of the time.

Johnson said the verdict was disappointing to him, and to the victims' families. But he said he believes in the jury system and he complimented the jurors for their attentiveness.

He added that he would try the case again, if he had it to do over.

"Our office is not afraid to try the tough cases ... and to be the voice for those who have no voices," Johnson said.

The allegations came to light after two sisters, ages 5 and 7, told their mother about a game Vargas played with them involving disrobing them and touching their private parts. The girls alleged that Vargas did so with all the girls, including an infant.

On Tuesday, as Vargas' attorneys continued presenting their case, jurors heard testimony from Kamala London, a developmental psychologist.

London testified that children are often influenced by peers or when they talk with other people about an event. Those interactions can shape a child's memory and sometimes lead them to report things that didn't occur.

London also said it was concerning that one of the alleged victims was interviewed seven times, during which the interviewer "prompted" her more than 100 times about possible sexual abuse. Such questioning could have led the child to give details that may not necessarily be true, London said.

However, London said that even when a child gives false statements, it does not necessarily mean they knowingly lied or had malicious intent.

Vargas' wife, Mabel Vargas, testified Tuesday about normal activities as she ran the day care, including feeding the children and taking them to school. The woman said her husband was most often in charge of driving the children to and from school.

Mabel Vargas, who has not been charged in connection with alleged abuse, said she was in Chile with her grandmother when her husband was arrested in December 2011.

Vargas was initially charged with 10 additional counts of lewdness after allegations that the man urinated in front of the girls with the bathroom door open. However, those charges were dismissed in July after a preliminary hearing because the girls' testimony did not reflect those allegations, according to prosecutors.

shunt@sltrib.com