Response to sister's request was tone deaf
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Dear Carolyn • My boyfriend and I decided on a wedding date that was convenient and would have great romantic meaning. The wedding is abroad and we traveled to make arrangements. We reserved the church, reception venue, musicians, photographer, almost everything! My older sister has been trying for over a year now to get pregnant, and she is undergoing medical treatment. She said she was almost sure she was pregnant (it turned out she wasn't), and asked us to change the date. I didn't even think much when I said no because we had already paid deposits and I like the date. She is very upset and she thinks I am wrong and selfish. She gave me a big wedding gift (so I can help pay for the wedding) so I think she thinks I must change the date. But I have a date, she doesn't; how can I know when would be a good time for her to have my wedding? Both things are important for each one. We have always been very close, but this is creating a really deep crack in our relationship. How can we move past this?

Sister

Dear Sister • We in the advice wing of the newsroom don't often get to say this, so I'll enjoy it while it lasts: Follow the money. When your sister thought she had a long-hoped-for due date that conflicted with your wedding date, your response — to the very person who apparently made your wedding-abroad-on-a-date-of-great-romantic-meaning possible — was "Tough." In so many words. The fact that she's actually not pregnant does not, as you suggest, prove the wisdom of your brush-off. It only makes it sound even more tone-deaf. Would it even have been possible to change your date to accommodate your sister? Maybe not; maybe the change fees would have been so prohibitive that "Tough" was the only practical answer. Please recognize, and admit to your sister, that you were too quick to dismiss the idea of rescheduling the wedding — because of course her presence meant more than a symbolic date ... yesss? Then ask her what, in a perfect world, she wants of you. Then, again, hear her out and don't "no" her out-of-hand — even if you end up not changing a thing.

Carolyn Hax's column runs Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays.