Husband's reaction is both wrong and cruel
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2013, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Dear Carolyn • My husband of over nine years has become "friends" with a female employee. He has texted this girl sometimes 50-100 times in a day. I have seen some of the texts. They talk about everything from music to movies to her boyfriend problems. He once spent over an hour on the phone with her while we were away visiting our friend, discussing her cheating boyfriend. I have asked him multiple times to develop a more professional relationship with her. Finally he got fed up with me asking, I guess, and did quit texting. However, I found out that he started chatting with her on Facebook, telling her it was a "safer" option. He says I am overreacting and need to see a counselor over my jealousy and "daddy issues" (my dad cheated on my mom) because he's at home "spending time" with me (as he texts). I say he needs to stop this "relationship" before it ends our marriage by becoming something he says it's not — or by my becoming fed up with asking him to stop contacting her. Who's right here?

Overreacting?

Dear Overreacting? • This pretty much defines an emotional affair. His intimacy is with her now, and his role for you is of obstacle to that intimacy. Add to that, he's being openly dismissive of your concerns by connecting them to your dad's behavior, which is not only a red herring, it's mean. You do need to make clear that this isn't about whether physical cheating has or hasn't happened or will happen. It's about what he fully admits is happening: His time with you is spent talking to her. He's taking his best self outside the marriage. That's what you're objecting to. Well, that and his utterly loveless response to your concerns. I type all this out knowing the chances are slim to none that he'll look inward, fall to his knees with remorse over his self-indulgence, and recommit himself to your marriage. But, the part where you state your feelings clearly is important. Then you say yes, you would like to see a counselor, with him. Also be ready for your next step by deciding how you'll respond to him. If he continues to defend his actions, are you at the "Please move out" point? If not, what will it take for you to get there?

Carolyn Hax's column runs Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays.