Pilot (Season 1, Episode 1)
Aggravated burglary: The Horseman trespasses into someone's stables.
Three counts of murder: The Horseman beheads the stable owner, Sheriff Corbin and a reverend.
Theft: The Horseman steals the stable owner's white horse.
Four counts of attempted murder: The Horseman fires a shotgun and an assault rifle at Ichabod, Abbie and two deputies.
Failure to comply: The Horseman refuses to put his hands on his head when the deputy commands him to. He doesn't have one or ears but it's still a crime.
Criminal mischief: The Horseman shoots up a patrol vehicle.
The Midnight Ride (Season 1, Episode 7)
Two counts of aggravated burglary: The Horseman breaks into the Freemasons' building and the lab.
Five counts of murder: The Horseman beheads four of the Freemasons and shoots a lab technician.
Two counts of attempted murder: The Horseman tries to kill Police Capt. Frank Irving and Ichabod.
Four counts of defiling a body: The Horseman hangs the Freemasons' heads in public with candles inside.
Two counts of criminal mischief: The Horseman slashes a painting of George Washington and destroys lab equipment.
Necromancer (Season 1, Episode 8)
Damaging a jail: The Horseman breaks the shackles constraining him in the ultraviolet-hex jail cell.
Attempted murder: The Horseman tries to kill Ichabod before zombie-Andy (Zandy?) stops him.
Escape from official custody: The Horseman escapes from the cell.
Bad Blood (Season 1, Episode 13)
Attempted murder: The Horseman tries to kill Jenny.
Kidnapping: The Horseman rides off with Katrina and holds her captive.
This Is War (Season 2, Episode 1)
Assault: The Horseman grabs Katrina by the neck.
The Kindred (Season 2, Episode 2)
Two counts of attempted murder: The Horseman tries killing Ichabod and Abbie. This would be three counts, but Franklinstein's monster is... arguably not a person?
The Weeping Lady (Season 2, Episode 5)
Attempted homicide: The Horseman tries to kill Ichabod.
Verdict • The Horseman may be ushering in Judgment Day, but if he faced his own judgment in the meantime for his 33 crimes (thus far), the Horseman would face a maximum 101 years behind bars on top of 22 life sentences. Then again, what's a lifetime to someone who has defied death once already?