Quantcast
Home » News
Home » News

Before a packed meeting, Interior Secretary Jewell sees harm visitors are causing at proposed Bears Ears monument

Published July 18, 2016 6:24 pm

After seeing petroglyphs, public lands chief gets taste of bitter monument split.
This is an archived article that was published on sltrib.com in 2016, and information in the article may be outdated. It is provided only for personal research purposes and may not be reprinted.

Bluff • Two-and-a-half hours into a scheduled three-hour public meeting on the future of public lands in southeastern Utah, Interior Secretary Sally Jewell asked for a show of hands: Who wanted to extend it 30 minutes?

It was stuffy. Cramped. Some in the Bluff Community Center couldn't see the stage.

Most raised their arms.



All told, two dozen local leaders spoke and more than five dozen people were chosen by a lottery system to express their concern for the future of the region, a common thread Jewell has repeatedly noted during her four-day visit.

One woman held up crossed fingers as the lottery numbers were read.

But with all sides gathered under one roof, the discussion sometimes took on the characteristics of the surrounding geology — dramatic rifts, and bright color.

Ute Tribe Chairman Shaun Chapoose turned away from a panel of Interior leaders to tell the crowd that a five-tribe coalition had hoped to secure a seat at the table with a 1.9-million-acre national monument proposal designed to protect the sacred lands.

"And here we sit," he said. "Are you at the table? You're talking."

San Juan County Commissioner Rebecca Benally followed to loud applause from monument opponents, saying the proposal has only sown discord between local American Indians, some of whom believe new restrictions will accompany a monument designation.

"We have known since 500 years ago and 200 years ago of broken promises and broken treaties," Benally said. She was among those who sometimes drowned out pro-monument speakers with boos.

Jewell has said the administration wants protections for the archaeologically rich area before President Barack Obama leaves office, either by using the Antiquities Act to designate a monument or signing legislation brought by Utah's delegation. Earlier this week, when Reps. Rob Bishop and Jason Chaffetz called for protection of 1.4 million acres here in their long-awaited Public Lands Initiative, Jewell expressed disappointment that it had taken so long.

Governor's Office policy director Cody Stewart said Saturday it might be worth setting both options aside to find another legislative solution.

"We have four or five months," he said. "We can do it."

The debate inside the community center played out in miniature at the entrance to the parking lot. In response to a sign held by monument supporter Peter Gatch that read "Let's make it happen," Monticello's George Rice asked, "Where are you from? Where do you live?"

"Park City," Gatch replied.

"Why don't you go make a monument in Park City?" Rice shouted back.

Asked by a reporter to explain his opposition, Rice was sorry to have raised his voice. But locals do not support the monument proposal, he said, and seasonal tourism is not the answer for a slumping local economy.

The pro-monument Gatch stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Notah Tahy, a Navajo man from Blanding who held a sign reading "No to a national monument" and fears that traditional Native American activities like gathering wood and hunting will be restricted in the meadows surrounding the twin buttes of Bears Ears.

Said Gatch: "I just love the beauty and wilderness of Utah."

On that point, they agree.

"Yep," said Tahy.

Inside, Navajo Nation President Russell Begaye had to raise his voice over cries of "Time!" and "Shut it off!" when he exceeded his two-minute allotment to praise the coalition proposal and urge the Interior officials to accept it.

"Your action will be one that will be remembered by our people for centuries," he persevered.

San Juan County Commissioner Bruce Adams drew raucous laughter from some monument proponents when he said "nobody really had settled here" before his own white ancestors.

Most speakers, however, were able to complete their thought without interruption. Jewell said afterward that she appreciated the respect that was shown.

Some of the debate hearkened back to President Bill Clinton's use of the Antiquities Act to designate Grand Staircase Escalante Monument in 1996.

"All it will do is cause problems," said Garfield County Commissioner Leland Pollock. "Take my word for it."

A tearful Jacqueline Orton, the widow of former U.S. Rep. Bill Orton, applauded Obama's initiative and said this situation is different from that one, which she believes cost her husband his office.

Then, she said, Orton found out about the designation when Clinton called him from Air Force One at 2 a.m.

"It was a bad process. We were lied to."

Yet many in Bluff believed this monument to be a foregone conclusion, too. It is human nature to exercise "unrighteous dominion," said former Blanding mayor Toni Turk, who warned that if Obama were to act unilaterally, he may cost Hillary Clinton a chance to win Utah.

A GOP president would "rescind" a monument designation, he said.

Jewell crammed in two more stops Saturday before the meeting, ending a whirlwind four-day tour in which she tried to understand the diverse landscape — to the extent that it's possible when consistently dogged by reporters, photographers, conservationists and congressional aides.

She first hiked at Comb Ridge – the massive sandstone partition separating east from west, high from low, for 50 miles.

There are 40 canyons in the ridge, said Friends of Cedar Mesa Executive Director Josh Ewing, and each has at least one archaeologically significant site.

Friends of Cedar Mesa President Vaughn Hadenfeldt told Jewell it's a misconception that the cliff-dwelling Basketmakers and Puebloan tribes lived a brutal life in the arid region. They enjoyed it enough, after all, to do artwork.

"This was a good place to live," he said.

Petroglyphs there include depictions of big-horn sheep, yucca plants, and wavy lines that archaeologists believe might demonstrate the path each artisan has traveled. The lines often emerge from a crack, Ewing said, evoking a deeper spiritual world from which their lives emerged.

One particularly dramatic panel featured discoloring along a crack that Hadenfeldt told Jewell he believes to be ashes smeared by a vandal.

Later, on the way to view the stark relief of the Wolfman Panel in Butler Wash — on which the artisan uncommonly portrayed the panel's namesake with musculature, instead of the usual stick limbs — Ewing showed where a C-shaped Pueblo shrine had sat in recent years.

Hikers have taken rocks to make cairns until nothing was left, he said, reiterating the need for better education as visitors continue to increase in the region.

Hadenfeldt showed Jewell where indigenous rock art recently gained a new neighbor, a heart encapsulating the initials "R+T."

BLM Director Neil Kornze said that no matter what on-paper protections are added, it's apparent that more resources are needed as the internet guides more and more people to cultural treasures that were once well-guarded secrets.

"One way or another, we have to up our game here," he said.

mpiper@sltrib.com

Twitter: @matthew_piper

 

 

 

 

 

USER COMMENTS
Reader comments on sltrib.com are the opinions of the writer, not The Salt Lake Tribune. We will delete comments containing obscenities, personal attacks and inappropriate or offensive remarks. Flagrant or repeat violators will be banned. If you see an objectionable comment, please alert us by clicking the arrow on the upper right side of the comment and selecting "Flag comment as inappropriate". If you've recently registered with Disqus or aren't seeing your comments immediately, you may need to verify your email address. To do so, visit disqus.com/account.
See more about comments here.
comments powered by Disqus