He instead sunk the 4-footer, with a rock-solid birdie that rolled to the center of the cup.
Emery then slipped his attempt just left, and the Bengals knew the state championship was theirs.
"I was having a problem with the flat stick all day, so I was extremely happy to see that putt fall", Byers said.
When the tie was announced, Byers and his teammates gathered and had a brief talk about not thinking too much about the playoff.
"I just said here we go, we've been playing good all week, let's just go play one more good hole and see what we can do here," Byers said.
That Lone Peak scrambled for the tie was a feat in itself.
The Knights shot the low team round of 286, led by Conner Copeland's 69 and Emery's 70, but they ended up falling short by two strokes on the playoff hole.
"I'm really proud of my guys for battling back today and showing the guts and determination they did," Lone Peak coach Tyler Pack said.
The battle for medalist honors saw a roller-coaster round between Region 2 opponents Austin Banz of West and Granger's Henry Leng, who were paired together on day two.
Banz struggled early, dropping three strokes, then watched Leng string together five consecutive birdies. Leng shot a day-two best 67, but Banz put together a birdie binge of his own to finish with a 137 to nip Leng by two shots.
"I was three up with like seven to go, and he hit that birdie streak," Banz said. "My putting was solid all tournament, and winning this tournament was something I always wanted to do." Class 5A team scores
Lone Peak: 298-286584
American Fork: 305-321626
Pleasant Grove: 306-325631
Class 5A individual top 10
Austin Banz, West: 67-70137
Henry Leng, Granger: 72-67139
Jacob Byers, Brighton: 70-71141
Nick Emery, Lone Peak: 75-70145
Connor Copeland, Lone Peak: 76-69145
Dylan Chugg, Fremont: 71-74145
Alex Herzog, Fremont: 75-70145
Charlie Duensing, Brighton: 73-73146
Rhett Rasmussen, Alta: 74-72146
Kalin Peterson, West Jordan: 72-74146