Yes. The opinions were certainly predictable. They are also hogwash.
Noel is the best shot-blocker in college basketball, a definite lottery pick torn-up knee or not. And he's also a better player for at least having experienced college for a year. His draft stock isn't going to drastically slip because of an injury. He's not going to never make the league because he's gotten hurt. He's not the first person to rip up his knee. He won't be the last.
NBA commissioner David Stern put the rule in for a reason: He simply wants guys coming into his league more physically and mentally equipped to handle the rigors of pro basketball. People will no doubt point to LeBron James, Kevin Garnett and Kobe Bryant as examples of those who thrived while jumping from preps to pros.
What they forget about are people like Johnathan Bender, Shaun Livingston and Robert Swift those who flamed out quickly.
Trust me. There are a lot more Robert Swifts than Kobe Bryants.
If anything, the rule needs to be two years. One and dones as they are called have turned college basketball into something of a farm system, and have robbed the sport of guys the general public can identify with.
It's also allowed the leeches of coaching John Calipari, please wave hello to thrive in recruiting and turn places like Kentucky into nothing more than shameful pit stops for players looking to strike it rich.
Making guys go to school for two years changes that. The answer, however, is not going back to high schoolers declaring for the draft.
And one major injury to a major star is not going to change that.