"The U.S. government shutdown continues to dominate the markets, weighing on market sentiment," said a report from analysts at Sucden Financial Research in London.
Economic indicators did not help, either. The Labor Department reported that the number of Americans seeking unemployment benefits remained near six-year lows, but while employers are have stopped laying off workers, the creation of new jobs has slowed in recent months.
Meanwhile, the Energy Department's Energy Information Administration said Wednesday that U.S. stockpiles of crude oil rose 5.5 million barrels, to 363.7 million barrels, last week. That was more than twice as much as market expectations and suggested weak demand.
Thursday's drop in the oil price came after strong gains Wednesday, when it rose more than $2 a barrel the most in two weeks on the prospect of more oil shipping between a key U.S. Midwest hub and the Gulf Coast.
Brent crude, a benchmark used to price imported crude used by many U.S. refineries, was up 52 cents to $109.71 in London.
In other energy futures trading on Nymex:
• Wholesale gasoline rose 3.58 cents to $2.6645 per gallon.
• Natural gas were unchanged at $3.542 per 1,000 cubic feet.
• Heating oil added 2.2 cents to $3.0147 per gallon.
Pamela Sampson in Bangkok contributed to this report.