Winston, who was a landslide Heisman winner last week, is joined on the first team by three Florida State teammates center Bryan Stork, kicker Roberto Aguayo and cornerback Lamarcus Joyner to give the top-ranked Seminoles more than any other school.
Florida State defensive tackle Timmy Jernigan made the second team, along with offensive tackle Cameron Erving. The Seminoles had six players on the three teams, the most of any school.
No. 2 Auburn, which plays Florida State on Jan. 6 in the BCS championship game in Pasadena, Calif., placed Heisman finalists Tre' Mason on the second team at running back and offensive lineman Reese Dismukes and Gregory Robinson on the third team.
Texas A&M Heisman finalist Johnny Manziel, last year's Heisman winner and All-American quarterback, made the second team. Alabama's AJ McCarron, another Heisman finalist, is the third-team quarterback for the second consecutive season.
The first-team receivers are Oregon State's Brandin Cooks, who leads the nation in yards receiving (139.2 per game), and Texas A&M's Mike Evans, who is averaging 20.3 yards a catch.
Texas Tech's Jace Amaro is the first-team tight end. The senior leads all tight ends in catches (98) and yards (1,240).
Joining Stork on the offensive line are Texas A&M tackle Jake Matthews and Alabama tackle Cyrus Kouandjio, as well as Baylor guard Cyril Richardson and Stanford guard David Yankey. Richardson and Yankey were second-team All-Americans last season.
Mosley and Sutton are on the first-team defense with Pittsburgh defensive tackle Aaron Donald, who won the Nagurski and Bednarik awards as the nation's best defensive player and the Outland and Lombardi as the country's best lineman.
Missouri's Michael Sam, the Southeastern Conference defensive player of the year, and Jackson Jeffcoat, the Big 12 defensive player of the year, are the defensive ends. UCLA's Anthony Barr and Ohio State's Ryan Shazier round out the linebackers.
Michigan State's Darqueze Dennard, one of the leaders of the nation's top-ranked defense, is the other cornerback with Joyner. The safeties are Mississippi's Cody Prewitt and Washington State's Deone Bucannon.
Tom Hornsey of Memphis made the first team as the punter.
Florida State helped the Atlantic Coast Conference put six players on the first team, to match the Pac-12 and SEC for the most from any conference.
AP All-America team list
Quarterback Jameis Winston, redshirt freshman, 6-foot-4, 229 pounds, Florida State.
Running backs Andre Williams, senior, 6-0, 227, Boston College; Ka'Deem Carey, junior, 5-10, 196, Arizona.
Tackles Jake Matthews, senior, 6-5, 305, Texas A&M; Cyrus Kouandjio, junior, 6-6, 310, Alabama.
Guards Cyril Richardson, senior, 6-5, 340, Baylor; David Yankey, senior, 6-5, 313, Stanford.
Center Bryan Stork, senior, 6-4, 300, Florida State.
Wide receivers Brandin Cooks, junior, 5-10, 186, Oregon State; Mike Evans, sophomore, 6-5, 225, Texas A&M.
Tight end Jace Amaro, junior, 6-5, 260, Texas Tech.
All-purpose player Jordan Lynch, senior, 6-0, 216, Northern Illinois.
Kicker Roberto Aguayo, redshirt freshman, 6-1, 203, Florida State.
Ends Michael Sam, senior, 6-2, 255, Missouri; Jackson Jeffcoat, senior, 6-5, 250, Texas.
Tackles Aaron Donald, senior, 6-0, 285, Pittsburgh; Will Sutton, senior, 6-1, 288, Arizona State.
Linebackers Anthony Barr, senior, 6-4, 248, UCLA; C.J. Mosley, senior, 6-2, 238, Alabama; Ryan Shazier, junior, 6-2, 230, Ohio State.
Cornerbacks Darqueze Dennard, senior, 5-11, 197, Michigan State; Lamarcus Joyner, senior, 5-8, 190, Florida State.
Safeties Cody Prewitt, junior, 6-2, 220, Mississippi; Deone Bucannon, senior, 6-1, 198, Washington State.
Punter Tom Hornsey, senior, 6-3, 210, Memphis.
Quarterback Johnny Manziel, sophomore, Texas A&M.
Running backs Tre' Mason, junior, Auburn; Bishop Sankey, junior, Washington.
Tackles Cameron Erving, junior, Florida State; Taylor Lewan, senior, Michigan.
Guards Gabe Jackson, senior, Mississippi State; Xavier Su'a-Filo, junior, UCLA.
Center Gabe Ikard, senior, Oklahoma.
Wide receivers Sammy Watkins, junior, Clemson; Davante Adams, sophomore, Fresno State.
Tight end Eric Ebron, junior, North Carolina.
All-purpose player Ty Montgomery, junior, Stanford.
Kicker Anthony Fera, senior, Texas.
Ends Vic Beasley, junior, Clemson; Shilique Calhoun, sophomore, Michigan State.
Tackles Timmy Jernigan, junior, Florida State; Kelcy Quarles, junior, South Carolina.
Linebackers Trent Murphy, senior, Stanford; Khalil Mack, senior, Buffalo; Chris Borland, senior, Wisconsin.
Cornerbacks Justin Gilbert, senior, Oklahoma State; Jason Verrett, senior, TCU.
Safeties Ha Ha Clinton-Dix, junior, Alabama; Ahmad Dixon, senior, Baylor.
Punter Drew Kaser, sophomore, Texas A&M.
Quarterback A.J. McCarron, senior, Alabama.
Running backs Carlos Hyde, senior, Ohio State; Ameer Abdullah, junior, Nebraska.
Tackles Jack Mewhort, senior, Ohio State; Gregory Robinson, sophomore, Auburn.
Guards John Urschel, senior, Penn State; Ryan Groy, senior, Wisconsin.
Center Reese Dismukes, junior, Auburn.
Wide receivers Allen Robinson, junior, Penn State; Jordan Matthews, senior, Vanderbilt.
Tight end Austin Seferian-Jenkins, junior, Washington.
All-purpose player Odell Beckham Jr., junior, LSU.
Kicker Jeff Budzien, senior, Northwestern.
Ends Marcus Smith, senior, Louisville; Jeremiah Attaochu, senior, Georgia Tech.
Tackles Ra'Shede Hageman, senior, Minnesota; Leonard Williams, sophomore, Southern California.
Linebackers Shayne Skov, senior, Stanford; Max Bullough, senior, Michigan State; Denicos Allen, senior, Michigan State.
Cornerbacks Ifo Ekpre-Olomu, junior, Oregon; Vernon Hargreaves III, freshman, Florida.
Safeties Jimmie Ward, senior, Northern Illinois; Ty Zimmerman, senior, Kansas State.
Punter Austin Rehkow, freshman, Idaho.