The BMC Racing Team leader had to force himself to the finish line. He had been part of the breakaway for essentially the entirety of the 130.7-mile stage, one that stretched from Panguitch across several scenic highways and byways to here, on the doorstep of Capitol Reef National Park. For nearly all of those miles, Schär had the lead or a taste of it.
The last few miles, he said, felt like slow motion. Schär battled through severe cramping on the descent after enduring over 10,100 feet of elevation gain. He called it the most difficult day of his racing career.
"It's more about the mind and not about the body," Schär said afterward. "You really have to suffer through that."
In the end, Schär beat the chasing peloton by about 2 seconds, finishing ahead of Team SmartStop's Jure Kocjan who claimed the yellow jersey and Serghei Tvetcov of Team Jelly Belly.
But Schär's suffering was the story of Stage 2. The day started with a mechanical malfunction in the morning when his shoes busted and his brand-new backup pair weren't yet broken in.
It wasn't a huge issue during his strong climb, but it became one during the descent, when he was forced to tuck down to gain speed. Millimeters make a difference in race shoes, he said, and it led to descent that he won't soon forget.
With 15 kilometers to go, Schär acknowledged he couldn't differentiate distances while pedaling. "I was too tired to see 15 and 10," he said. "I couldn't make a difference anymore."
Tuesday's second stage looked like it would play out in more predictable fashion, where the leaders eventually become engulfed by the peloton in the final half-hour.
But when rival Joey Rosskompf dropped his direct pursuit with less than two miles remaining, Schär knew his path was clear.
He just wasn't sure his body could cooperate.
"There were some points in this downhill where I thought, 'OK, now I can stop on the side of the road,' " he joked.
Kocjan, the 29-year-old Slovenian, made his own move on the descent going from the back of the pack to near the front in the final stretch to earn another second-place finish and the yellow jersey going into Wednesday's third stage from Lehi to Miller Motorsports Park in Tooele.
"This is incredible," he said. "We are a small team, a low-budget team, and we have here seven pro continental and world tour teams."
While Team SmartStop is the talk of the first two stages as the Tour heads north, Tuesday's race will be remembered for Schär's exhausting ride.
Tuesday was the toughest day of his career. Just ask him, he'll tell you.
Tour of Utah Stage 2
O Panguitch to Torrey • 130.7 miles
1. Michael Schär (Switzerland), BMC Racing Team, 5 hours, 3 minutes
2. Jure Kocjan (Slovenia), Team SmartStop, +:02 seconds
3. Serghei Tvetcov (Romania), Jelly Belly p/b Maxxis, +:02
4. Kiel Reijnen (U.S.), UnitedHealthCare Pro Cycling, +:02
5. Toms Skujins (Latvia), Hincapie Sportswear Devo Team, +:02
6. Cadel Evans (Australia), BMC Racing Team, +:02
7. Tanner Putt (U.S., Park City), Bissell Devo Team, +:02
8. Luca Wackerman (Italy), Team Lampre-Merida +:02
9. Wilco Kelderman (Netherlands), Belkin-Pro Cycling Team, +:02
10. Brent Bookwaler (U.S.), BMC, +:02
After two stages:
1. BMC Racing Team
2. Team Lampre-Merida
3. Hincapie Sportswear Devo Team
4. Bissell Devo Team
6. UnitedHealthCare Pro Cycling Team
7. Jamis-Hagens Berman p/b Sutter Home
8. Trek Factory Racing
9. Team SmartStop
10. Drapac Professional Cycling
Stage 3 preview
O Wednesday, 11 a.m.
• Lehi to Miller Motorsports Park
Distance • 118.3 miles
Elevation gain • 3,953 feet